Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Serious Question

Leyden H.S. is on the precipice of making a monumental shift in how education is brought to its students. It is quite possible that beginning with next year, each student will be given a computer to use in school. This device has not been decided upon yet, but it is very possible it will have all of the capabilities of web browsing and will be able to access all of the tools that the internet offers. What I'd like to know is how you feel a device with this power could make you a better student. How do you think I could use it on a daily basis to make what we learn in class more accessible/understandable/applicable in your life? Are you aware of or do you currently use any web-based apps/programs/websites that you feel enhance your learning experience? Does this 1-to-1 computer idea excite you or scare you? Even you seniors, who won't be around to experience it, do you see this as a good course of action for LHS? Discuss amongst yourselves.......

21 comments:

  1. First! Woo! I think that this laptop idea could help and hurt Leyden. The problem that I see with it is that with so many laptops working in one day, I'd be worried that one: the laptops would be working very slowly and two: the laptops would die during the day. However, I also think the laptops could help us. When you have a laptop at your disposal all day, it makes getting information for a class a lot easier. You have a ton of tools to use when you have technology, and I think that would help us learn and understand things better. I think the computer idea is exciting but at the same it's unknown to us since we've never had a laptop policy like this before. One program that helps me a lot right now is google docs! It's so helpful! I love it because I can post something on google docs at home and then open it at school. It's quick and easy to understand and it's a great program. Next year I'm going to be a senior so I think that this idea would be great for me. I could see how I like the laptop idea and test it out for the year and then at the end of the year, I think it would be good for the school to ask seniors what they're overall opinion of the laptop system is to further decide if it should continue on or not. Overall, I'm on the fence about the laptop idea, but leaning towards the pro side!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I support this because pretty much all the homework i recieve now is on the computer and if i had a computer to take everywhere with me I could do my homework anytime I wanted. After school i am usually not home till 6 or later because of sports and i spend a lot of time at west where i cannot do my homework if it is online. If we had laptops that we could use anytime I could get my homework done quicker and maybe even before I got home.

    ReplyDelete
  3. For you as a teacher I think it will be much easier. You won't have to worry about getting worksheets printed and stuff like that. I think students will be more involved in class that way but that also means that they might get distracted by the web and you will have to keep an eye on them. We'll never know how it'll work until we try.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think the laptops are more of a distraction than anything. But I do see the upsides and how they can help the learning experience. The laptops would probably make it easier for any student to access google documents, web assignments or information distributed by their teacher. The laptops would merely get rid of that old excuse "I didn't have a computer to type the essay" or "my internet wasn't working."

    I think there's more bad than good, but as a senior, I'll never get to know whether they pan out or not. Either way the school goes on this issue, I can see the idea being plausible and applicable, but I can also see it utterly failing.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Although it would be easier for teachers to grade and see the progress of students a lot easier, the idea scares me. What ever happened to some good old paper and pencil? Will it take away all interaction between students and teachers? Or what happens when the network goes down? I don't think people could really totally benefit from it, but I guess we'll see what happens.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think that having computers would be awesome! Most of the homework I get is online anyways, so having a laptop with me would be easier for me to do my homework whenever I wanted to. A problem with everyone having laptops though would be that students would lose them and break them, which would cost money to fix. I still think we would all benefit from having them.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think this would be a good idea because this year I have been doing a lot of hw online. It would help by keeping my files organized and help you as teacher by beeing able to turn in hw online. I would use it to check the math problems online to check if I am correct. Although there could be some problems with having a computer for each student. I feel like it would take away from traditional learning and might hurt the students in the long run. I am still excited about having a computer.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm going to give2 you my honest opinion of this one to one computing thing. Even though i am fairly young, I absolutley love writing things and taking notes and keeping it old school. This year, one of my classes has us doing notes and another class we use one or two apps that "help us" learn better. Ugh! I really miss the regular teacher stands and teaches and we take notes and take quizzes and tests on paper! But then again who am I to stop this revolution. It probably will happen and if it does, i have to look on the bright side. Maybe for math, we can have some programs that can help use better apply what we learn. I dont really know, Google will come up with something.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I love the idea of a laptop that students could carry around with them. The hassle of carrying everything would be gone when they could take notes and access books online. It would also be a lot easier for the teachers because they wouldn't have to worry about printing everything. Then again, the laptop could be a huge distraction for the students in class. Overall, i think the laptops could both benefit and harm the education of the students.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Introducing more and more technology into the classroom is a necessary step, although it might be hard to see benefits in the short run. At first, the laptops will be hampered by slow networks and annoying glitches, as with every new technology that is introduced, but long term benefits will be totally worth it. Students will have access to hundreds of new databases, things like Google docs, days spent in the computer lab will no longer be necessary, and some classes are already introducing electronic textbooks. In 10-15 years, I can't imagine that most schools that have the necessary funding will still be using wasteful pen and paper in their classes. This transition, I think, is inevitable and we should just get it over with next year. The system will definitely be flawed at the start, but over time it will just improve the overall experience.

    ReplyDelete
  11. considering that my books have built up more dust than my grandma, and my muscles have lost so much strength from only carrying a notebook, im definately all for the 1-1 computing :D

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi Jackson! You should record yourself teaching EACH lesson :) Even though you probably won't do it...but, students who aren't able to be present in class can access the lecture and can learn from home! This one-to-one student laptop thing can be easier on the weight load from the books we get each year. I do think that humans are relying more on technology and aren't finding things out for themselves though. It could mean that humans are getting lazier, but then again getting smarter from coming up with such technologies. I think that this new system is unfair for students like THE SENIORS because we don't get to experience it. :/

    ReplyDelete
  13. I doesn't really matter because I'm used to carrying heavy books and doing much of my homework online, but I would definitely like to see what the outcome would be if my senior year was all electronic

    ReplyDelete
  14. I think computers are great, but at the same time they scare me. Having gone through not having electricity twice in this school year already, I know what it feels like not being able to do your homework because it's online. COmputers are awesome and they have so much valuable information, but what happens when the power oes out? Computers in school would definelty help because they would not only cut down on paper waste, they would also allow students to access all sort of information at any given time, in just a matter of seconds.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I am certain that introducing computers will bring many benefits. There may be a few annoyances with this, however after a month students will easily be able to adjust. Students will also be able to help their teachers, just because the younger generation are a lot more advanced with new technology. Computers will be very convenient for students to move around, having their homework, textbooks and ideas all in a single laptop students will be very happy. By 2020 I am sure most schools will have transitioned to this new way for schooling so for Leyden to do it early is just a way to get ahead in what will happen.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think the laptops are a great idea. Having access to a computer in all your classes will help because you are presented with so much more information. They also may have some problems like if they die and then you are left with nothing in your class. This year we use laptops in my U.S. history class and the first few weeks there were many problems, slow network, many didn’t work, and did not get charged. It is interesting to see what it will be like being all electronic senior year.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Terrible idea. Don't get me wrong, I am a huge fan of trees, however the tendency for computers to break down or malfunction is far too great to consider this approach even somewhat reliable.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I think this the laptops, netbooks or whatever is decided upon is a horrible idea because it will be more distracting to each student and there is no really efficient way to monitor students and see if they are taking notes or playing angry birds. Besides, it is extremely hard to take math notes or do any mathematics on a computer unless students have a tablet or special plug in tablet (Bamboo+ Bamboo pen) were they can actually "write" their notes electronically . Also maintenance and excuses (i forgot my laptop at home, again) will happen way to often and time will be wasted. So far, pen and paper have done well and a paper doesn't Malfunction (or freeze). The way I see it, there are not nearly as much advantages as disadvantages. Also, lets not forget, that if the network happens to crash, for some apparent reason, the laptops will be as useful as paperweights because no one will be able to log in.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think it's a pretty bad idea i mean sure there are some positives to it but overall i don’t think it won't work out so smoothly especially the first years some people won’t be able to keep up, the laptops or whatever won't be incredibly fast so that will slow the lesson down I can't imagine using a laptop in class for math except for like submitting homework i guess or taking multiple choice quizzes but who cares I'm a senior so you all have fun with it, can't wait to hear how it goes for all of you next year with them:D

    ReplyDelete
  20. i mean that i don't think it will work out smoothly

    ReplyDelete
  21. All i care about is getting all of our textbooks DIGITALLY. Other than that, my back could care less.

    ReplyDelete