in the spirit of doing proofs by mathematical induction, i've decided to present my stance on the art of winning an argument. first off, i must admit that i consider myself a pacifist and am loathe to engage someone in an argument if at all possible, but that doesn't mean that i don't arm myself with baseline mathematical proof techniques when i do.
i was having a pleasant argument with one of my colleagues the other day, which aren't two words you see together often, but really it was. no one's feelings were hurt, both parties made compelling defenses of their stance and we left the main crux of our disagreement unresolved, but with intent to re-up the contest after more research. as i was arguing my point, i noticed that the person i was conversing with was using some words that i try to avoid in arguments; always and never.
there are times when proving something "works" is by assuming it doesn't and then providing a counterexample to that negation. sort of like a double-negative; "i didn't do nothing wrong". well, if you didn't do nothing wrong, then you must've done something wrong. for some people, arguing, and on a bigger scale, life at times, is not so much about proving why their belief is correct, but more about pointing out why their opponent's assertion is wrong. i call these people "hole-pokers".as in, they're always trying to poke holes in other people's ideas.
words like always and never open you up to negation by counterexample. all your opponent (and i'm trying to think of a better word here, because opponent sounds so combative, but i'm drawing a blank) has to do is point out ONE instance to the contrary and your argument loses credibility. and i'm sure many lawyers will tell you that once you lose credibility, you lose everything.
avoid these words children. they become easy targets for the people of the world who only try to bring you down. in fact, now that you've been armed with such powerful reasoning skills, all you really have to do is stretch out your argument until the other person (found one!) uses one of these words and you can pounce. proof of falsity by counterexample. boom goes the dynamite. swim in the spoils of your victory.
Next time I argue, I will never use the word never. I will always try to avoid words like always and never.
ReplyDelete